Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (2023)

Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (1)

The Duchess of Windsor... Royal love and crisis (Image: Getty)

Invalid email

We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. More info

Wallis Simpson has always fascinated me. As a child, I pored over images of her in my granny's Coronation book from 1937, the year Edward VIII should have been crowned but wasn't. The villainess of the piece was the ruthless American social climber who had stolen England's King. Everyone knew that.

Related articles

  • Royal Family tree: Is Queen Elizabeth II related to King Henry VIII?
  • William and Kate braced for painful weekend – Queen heartbroken

I didn't question this version of her story; why would I? She certainly looked the part in the photos; stroking a lapdog like arch baddie Ernst Blofeld in the James Bond films whilst sporting a vast emerald ring.

Fast forward to a couple of years ago when I was writing my first novel, The Governess, based on the true story of royal nanny Marion Crawford, the young Scotswoman who was governess to the Queen and Princess Margaret.

In the plot I constructed, Wallis Simpson appeared in a scene with Marion.

It was only meant to be a brief appearance, just a couple of lines, but she ended up taking over the whole chapter.

(Video) Queen Elizabeth, The Queen Mother: The Reluctant Queen - British Royal Documentary

As with all my historical novels, I read everything about my subject I could get my hands on. And the more research I did, the less evidence there seemed for Wallis's reputation as a heartless gold-digger who schemed to be Queen of England.

Many contemporaries — Diana Cooper and Chips Channon, to name but two — mention what a wonderful hostess she was, how every detail at her parties was perfection.

But they also say that she was nice to bores, that she noticed people with no-one to talk to and drew them in. It was this generosity and her lack of sycophancy that first attracted the Prince of Wales.

There was much speculation at the time, and still is, about what exactly he saw in her. She was attractive and stylish, but she was no great beauty. Unsavoury rumours circulated about her sexual expertise.

The simple truth seems to be that they just hit it off. Accustomed to being smarmed over from morning till night, Edward found her breezy American ways refreshing. She also encouraged him in his ambitions to modernise. "You're the only person who's ever been interested in my job, Wallis," he told her.

Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (5)

New view: Chips Channon called Wallis a wonderful hostess (Image: Getty)

They had other, darker things in common, too. As my research took me deeper into their backgrounds, I found that both were scarred by traumatic childhoods. Wallis had suffered poverty and insecurity as the daughter of a Baltimore widow while Edward's royal upbringing, outwardly privileged, was in reality an insular world populated by cruel nannies, a chilly mother and a terrifyingly shouty father.

Both, too, had experienced addiction at its worst. Wallis's first husband "Win" Spencer was a violent alcoholic whilst heroin drove Edward's younger brother George to the brink of suicide. I was astonished to discover that it was Edward who saved him, nursing George back to health, sitting devotedly by his bedside night and day during the dangerous period of withdrawal.

(Video) A Tragic Love Story | The Other Prince William (Royal Family Documentary) | Timeline

Wallis, who had served her time at the bedside of an addict, would have understood as few others could have.

It is hard, once you know all this, to see the two of them as the selfish egotists posterity would have us believe. My softening feeling about Wallis was further bolstered by the discovery of what I think of as her "Cinderella years".

Few people know that when she came to London in 1928 she was cold-shouldered by society as a penniless divorcee. But everyone knows that, a few years later, she captured the heart of the Prince of Wales.

Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (6)

From 'penniless divorcee' to socialite and wife of the Prince of Wales (Image: Getty)

So what happened in between? Some lonely and difficult years, is what. So the Wallis of my trilogy of novels about women who fell out with the House of Windsor is funny and kind.

Revisionism is addictive, and it wasn't long before I started examining the abdication itself. As already mentioned, the traditional version is that the socially ambitious American used the King.

But was the truth in fact the opposite; that Edward used Wallis to escape his royal destiny? As the Prince of Wales, he never bothered to conceal how much he hated "stunting", as he called public appearances. He complained about being "chained to the banqueting table as other men are chained to the workbench".

Becoming king was a nightmare come true; he sobbed for a full hour on his mother's diamond-encrusted bosom once his father George V had breathed his last.

Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (7)

What did Edward want from Wallis? (Image: Getty)

(Video) Foyle's War S01E01 - The German Woman / full episode

He knew he was temperamentally unsuited to the throne and that others could do it better. Especially as, due to his childhood, I suspect he did not want children.

Given producing an heir is pretty much the main job of the monarch, this would obviously have complicated things. And so, when he realised that neither nation nor Establishment would accept a foreign divorcee as Queen, did he see this as an advantage?

Was the wrong woman in the eyes of Church, State and Empire exactly the right wife for him?

The more I read, wrote and thought about the events leading up to December 1936, the more logical this theory seemed. It explains what otherwise makes no sense.

Related articles

  • Queen’s great-nephew is set to start training with the...
  • Queen handed 'perfect olive branch' to finally END Megxit trouble

Edward did so many strange things. He picked dangerous fights he knew he would lose, and deliberately sought the worst advice, keeping on the stuffed shirts from his father's time instead of recruiting advisers of his own.

Moving reluctantly into a few poky rooms in Buckingham Palace, he did not even bother to have his boxes unpacked. It was if he knew he would not be staying long.

Most bizarrely, he insisted on marrying Wallis before his Coronation and not afterwards when his massive popularity would have meant he could do what he wanted. So why didn't he wait a mere few more months, when he might have got away with it? Because he didn't want to get away with it, is the only possible answer. He wanted out. But what of Wallis?

Popular belief has her plotting to ascend the throne too. But as I show in The Duchess, the second novel of my royal trilogy, I don't think she ever expected to be Queen, or even to be Edward's wife. Why am I so sure? Because Wallis had personally known his two previous mistresses and saw both dumped without warning.

(Video) Meghan Markle - Harry and Meghan Vs The Monarchy 2021

He must surely have expected the same to happen to her.That the relationship continued when Edward became King was a surprise, but a rather bigger one was being made to divorce her estranged husband Ernest.

Ernest Simpson is usually viewed as a pitiable cuckold, but Wallis was truly fond of her kind and supportive second husband.

She planned to return to him once the royal relationship was over. But Edward, determined to drive them apart, waited until Wallis was in Paris to summon Ernest and order him to divorce his wife.


    When Wallis returned, she was appalled to find her marriage over by royal decree.

    Things were moving rapidly out of her control and I imagine that, as the abdication crisis gathered momentum, Wallis was increasingly appalled at the situation in which she found herself.

    Too late, I suspect, she realised that Edward planned the whole thing.

    Has Wallis Simpson been cruelly misjudged by history? (11)

    A fresh look at the Duchess (Image: Welbeck)

    This is the narrative I set out in The Duchess. Knowing that I was presenting her from a fresh angle felt timely; the idea that other "truths" lie behind controversial royal figures has never been more current.

    The Duchess by Wendy Holden (Welbeck, £12.99) is out now. Call Express Bookshop on 020 3176 3832. Free UK P&P for orders over £20

    Related articles

    • John Deacon Queen: Why did bass player John Deacon leave Queen?
    • Elvis: Teenage British co-star shares memories
    (Video) They Were Her Property: White Women as Slave Owners in the American South


    Was Edward VIII happy with Wallis? ›

    His affections towards her, even after their marriage, was described by Borman as “clingy and cloying.” “He just wanted her all to himself,” said Borman. “He was quite suffocating when it came to his love for Wallis. That's why there were rumors of her having an affair -- to escape.

    How tall was Wallis Simpson? ›

    Why didnt Wallis Simpson have children? ›

    Did Wallis Simpson have children? Wallis had no children with any of her husbands. Many historians believe that a case of mumps in Edward's youth rendered the Duke of Windsor infertile, and this was the reason they never conceived.

    How old was Wallis Simpson when married? ›

    A few weeks later, at 42, Edward gave up the throne to be with Wallis, who was 40 and still married.

    Did Edward VIII ever regret abdicating? ›

    And the infamous moment that will forever have Elizabeth's uncle and his wife etched in the history books was not something the Duke of Windsor ever lamented. Says Pasternak, "The duke always said that not once did he regret the abdication, because he was so happy."

    Who would be King if Edward had not abdicated? ›

    Had the Duke of Windsor not abdicated and remained King until his death, who would be the sovereign now? ASSUMING that he married Mrs Simpson and this union produced no children, as was the case, his eldest surviving brother, Henry, Duke of Gloucester, would have become King Henry IX in 1972 at the age of 72.


    1. BENNETT OF THE 5 TOWNS Compilation
    (Staffordshire Film Archive)
    2. Who Was The Real Queen Victoria? | A Monarch Unveiled | Timeline
    (Timeline - World History Documentaries)
    3. No Mercy - Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood (Starnacht am Wörthersee 10.08.2002) (VOD)
    4. Learn English Through Story -Solve all problems Part 2 -English Listening
    (English Story for Listening Practice)
    5. The Russian Revolution After The Crimean War | Crimean War | Timeline
    (Timeline - World History Documentaries)
    6. The Royal House of Windsor Biggest Secrets - Prince Philip - Royal Documentary
    (UK Documentary)
    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Van Hayes

    Last Updated: 12/11/2022

    Views: 6022

    Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

    Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Van Hayes

    Birthday: 1994-06-07

    Address: 2004 Kling Rapid, New Destiny, MT 64658-2367

    Phone: +512425013758

    Job: National Farming Director

    Hobby: Reading, Polo, Genealogy, amateur radio, Scouting, Stand-up comedy, Cryptography

    Introduction: My name is Van Hayes, I am a thankful, friendly, smiling, calm, powerful, fine, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.